واکاوی جلوه‌های گروتسک در رمان لعبة النسیان بر اساس رویکرد باختین

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 داانشگاه بین المللی امام خمینی

2 دانشیار گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه بین المللی امام خمینی

3 استادیار گروه زبان و ادبیات عربی دانشگاه بین المللی امام خمینی

چکیده

گروتسک، گفتمانیست هنری-ادبی موجد تمهیداتی برای برساختن آمیزه‌های عاطفی ناهمگن و ایجاد بلاتکلیفی تمام‌عیار، که رمزگشایی صحنه‌های دیریابش، به غنی‌سازی فنی-محتوایی اثر می‌انجامد. گروتسک خط ‌مقدم نبرد با قطعیت‌گرایی و منادی جهانی ناتمام بوده و در سایه محتوای فلسفی جهان‌نگری‌اش، افشاگر چهره بی‌پرده جهان دست‌نیافتنی در قالب بازنمایی همزمان تقابلهای دوسویه است. رویکرد باختینی گروتسک، متمرکز بر ریشه‌های سرخوشانه ادبیات مردمی، در قالب ویژگیهای: ناهماهنگی دوگانی‌ها، افراط، تنانگی، فروکاهی، زبان تهاجمی، و.مطلق ناهنجاری، با امکان‌سازی برای بازشناسی قابلیتهای متن روایی بواسطه عینیت‌بخشی به جهان‌نگری حقیقت‌جو و آزادیخواهی جزمیت‌ستیزشان، مزایای انکارناپذیری دارد. رمان لعبة النسیان، اثر "محمد برادة" مراکشی، کانونی از تجربه‌گرایی پیرامون تمهیدات ادبیات چندآوا، به‌ویژه گروتسک بوده، در این زمینه نمونه‌سازی‌های شاخصی دارد. بازنمود ادبیاتی ویژگیهای گروتسکی ذیل جلوه‌های گروتسکی: ناهماهنگی، تنانگی نابهنجار، فضاسازی گروتسکی، نابهنجاریهای شبقی، هرزه‌گویی و.کفرگویی، ومضمون دیوانگی بررسی و در پاسخ به روحیه متداول‌شده تک‌سویه‌نگری و توهم همه‌چیزدانی تحلیل گردید. با بازکاوی نمونه‌های "لعبةالنسیان"، متکی بر روش توصیفی-تحلیلی، در‌یافتیم: براده با گستاخی ابداع در آمیزه‌های ناهمگن، و برملاسازی مرسومات قبول‌عام‌یافته، مخاطب را به امکان‌مندی نظمی سراپا متفاوت، در شناخت جهان همه چیز نسبی می‌رساند و درباره مرجعیت‌های نهادینه اقتدارگرایان ، ادعای یکه‌بودگی، جاودانگی و بحث‌ناپذیری را با فروکاهی امور والای تقدیس‌یافته به خاکدان ماده، درهم‌می‌شکند.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Analysis of grotesque effects in the novel The Game of Forgetting by the Bakhtin Approach

نویسندگان [English]

  • Razieb Sadrikhanloo 1
  • Alireza Shaikhi 2
  • Abdulali Alebooye Langroudi 2
  • Mostafa Parsaeipour 3
1 Imam Khomeini International University
2 Associate Professor, Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Imam Khomeini International University
3 Assistant Professor, Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Imam Khomeini International University
چکیده [English]

Title:

Analysis of grotesque effects in the novel The Game of Forgetting by the Bakhtin Approach

Introduction:

Grotesque, the artistic-literary discourse, makes technical arrangements for the creation of heterogeneous emotional mixtures and the creation of all-encompassing uncertainty, the decipherment of his long-awaited scenes, leading to the technical and content enrichment of the work. The grotesque is at the forefront of the battle with the certainty and it’s the herald of an unfinished world. In the light of the philosophical content of its worldview, it reveals the blunt face of the unattainable world in the form of a simultaneous representation of the two-dimensional contrasts. Bakhtinian grotesque approach focuses on the merry roots of popular literature, in the form of features: inconsistency of dual contrasts, exaggeration, corporeal centeredness, degrading, aggressive language, and absolute anomalies, It has undeniable benefits by enabling the recognition of the capabilities of the narrative text by objectifying their truth-seeking worldview and anti-dogma libertarianism.

The novel “The Game of Forgetting”, by the Moroccan “Mohamed Barrada”, is a center of experimentalism on the arrangements of polyphonic literature, especially the grotesque, and has created significant prototypes in this field. Literary representation of grotesque characteristics the following grotesque manifestations: disharmony, abnormal corporeal centeredness, grotesque atmosphere, erotic abnormalities, profanity and billingsgate, and the theme of madness were examined and analyzed in response to the prevailing spirit of one-sidedness and illusion of omniscience.

Mohamed Barrada, a pioneering author whose novels are indebted to Bakhtin's discourse theory, recognizes the carnival-grotesque tradition in his laudatory critiques, He has adapted some of the preparations of grotesque realism to his masterpiece of narrative, and has paved the way for the benefit of the rich but veiled Moroccan popular culture.

he engaged in literary modeling under the sub-categories of dialogism, For example, he has attempted to create scences focusing on Grotesque wonders, as well as the philosophical and ideological dimensions considered by Bakhtin, And his creative scenes and images each somehow pursue the goals of grotesque discourse. Barrada is also one of the Arab exprimentalist novelists, and Grotesque's discourse, intersects with the new exprimentalist novel, on the subject of border crossing and transgression, norm-breaking, non-dissemination of consideration, embracing with all possibilities and the rejection of pre-determined categories.

The main question of this paper is how grotesque elements and images have been effective in inducing the ideas of truth-seeking and exposing grotesque discourse and adapting the concepts of pluralism and confronting the serious tone of the Domineering official culture.

In pursuing the research question, we first identified the theoretical topics of grotesque and then examined the grotesque effects of “The Game of Forgetting” and analyzed the inductive concepts of its examples.



Methodology:

In analyzing grotesque examples, we have followed a descriptive-analytical method based on library data processing, and our focus has been on Bakhtin's grotesque approach, based on the merry roots of popular literature, and in the form of features: inconsistency of dual contrasts, exaggeration, corporeal centeredness, degrading, aggressive language, and absolute anomalies, and by applying the method of technical critique and carefully examining the necessary techniques of a particular literary genre, we have sought the literary representation of grotesque features in the form of grotesque manifestations, including: disharmony, abnormal corporeal centeredness, grotesque atmosphere, erotic abnormalities, profanity and billingsgate, and the theme of madness.



Results and Discussion:

Examining the examples of each of the grotesque features of “The Game of Forgetting”, we find:

1. Expressing contradictions in the behavior and movements of the characters or the state of phenomena and being in a situation inconsistent with their position, in Barrada’s work, is a solution to create a heterogeneous and challenging mixture of emotions to discuss the idea of a fluid and possible world by rejecting necessary principles It is undisputedness and completeness.

2. In the abnormal corporeal centeredness and extreme attention to the lower parts of the limbs, as the ways of communication with the earth and the material world, the principle of degradation is considered by the author to question the pretense of excellence and sanctity and deliberately highlighted distinctions and replaces the idea of equality and universal anti-class freedom.

3. In Barrada’s grotesque atmospheres, the induction of negative, harassing, and anxious emotional states, In addition to creating a heterogeneous emotional duality and laying the groundwork for grotesque indecisiveness and indecision, somehow aims to normalize our view of the second half of life, the death, which is followed by a new birth. Sometimes this is done in the realm of sacred matters, such as the example of the Mushatfah.

4. Erotic abnormalities are the culmination of the construction of emotional dichotomies and are tied to killing in order to intensify them. Another purpose - according to the narrator's groundworks in order to to raise the examples - is to set aside considerations in this area and expose it as a real part of life that requires a logical design to find a solution like other phenomena and should be known. That secrecy, as claimed by chaste purposes, is not the solution.

5. The vilifications in language of grotesque, by connecting the object to the lower extremities, acquires a destructive-reconstructive nature and so-called carnivalous, and with the help of the capabilities of the inferior culture, unlike the official repressive culture, creates creativity and behind the profanity, the liberating truth of freedom, Has lies. The deliberate choice of blasphemous concepts indicates a deliberate massification of the mass of ideas and images distorts the whole truth considered to be complete.



Conclusion:

Thus Barrada, of an exemplary spirit of intolerance and rejection, seeks to recall the excluded elements and to combine heterogeneous elements and that allows another view of a world with a more orderly structure under the concept of relativity. And by projecting any indisputable ideas and dogmatic actions, and believing in the boundaries crossing and coexistence of phenomena, heralds high decisive values such as freedom, happiness, justice, accepting others, rejection of dogmatism and reconcile all the parts of the world again.



Keywords: Grotesque, The Game of Forgetting, Degradation, Corporeal Centeredness, Billingsgate.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Grotesque
  • The Game of Forgetting
  • Degradation
  • Corporeal Centeredness
  • Billingsgate
منابع و مآخذ
باختین، میخاییل، (۱۳۹۷)، پرسش­های بوطیقای داستایفسکی، ترجمه سعید صلح­جو، چاپ­دوم، تهران: نیلوفر.
برادة، محمد، (2003)، لعبة.النسیان، الرباط: دار الأمان.
پوینده، محمدجعفر، (۱۳۹۶)، درآمدی بر جامعه­شناسی ادبیات، چاپ دوم، تهران: نشرچشمه.
تامسن، فیلیپ، (1390)، گروتسک در ادبیات، فرزانه طاهری، تهران:نشر مرکز.
تسلیم جهرمی، فاطمه و طالبیان، یحیی، (1390)، «تلفیق احساسات ناهمگون و متضاد (گروتسک) در طنز و مطایبه»، فنون ادبی، سال سوم، شماره 1: 1-20.
جزینی، جواد، (1370)، «ناهمگونی احساس، نگاهی به کتاب گروتسگ در ادبیات نوشته فلیپ تامپسون»، سوره، شماره ویژه ادبیات داستانی: 102-105. DOI: i10.52547/jls.6.17.5
جلیلی، رضا، و مشهور، پروین­دخت، (1396)، «تحلیل مؤلفه­های کارناوالی در مجموعه­ی هوای تازه از احمد شاملو با رویکرد به آراء باختین»، مطالعات نقد ادبی، سال دوازدهم، شماره 46: 69-94.
حسینی، فرشته سادات، (1398)، گروتسک در هنر و ادبیات ایران، قزوین: ادیب.
رحال، عبدالواحد، (٢٠١٩)، «خطاب الغروتیسک فی الروایة الجزائریة، مقاربة فی روایتی: رأس المحنة لعزالدین جلاوجی، والولی الطاهر یرفع یدیه بالدعاء للطاهر وطار»، مجلة إشکالات فی اللغة والأدب، مجلد:٨، عدد٢: 145-166.
شربتدار، کیوان، و انصاری، شهره، (1391)، «گروتسک و ادبیات داستانی، بررسی مفهوم گروتسک و کاوش مصداق­های آن در داستانهای کوتاه شهریار مندنی پور»، ادبیات پارسی معاصر، سال دوم، شماره دوم: 105-121.
مکاریک، ایرنا.ریما، (1388)، دانشنامه نظریه­های ادبی معاصر، مهران مهاجر و محمد نبوی، تهران:آگه.
نولز، رونلد، (۱۳۹۱)، شکسپیر و کارناوال پس از باختین، ترجمه رویا پورآذر، تهران: هرمس.
 
Bakhtin, Mikhail. M (1984), Rabelais and His World, Translated by Helene Iswolsky, Indiana University Press, Bloomington.
Bakhtin, Mikhail. M, (2017), Dostoyevsky's Poetique Questions, translated by Saeed Solhjo, 2nd edition, Tehran: Niloofar. (In Persian)
Barada, Mohammad, (2003), The Game of Forgetting, Al-Rabat: Dar Al-Aman. (In Arabic)
Dentith, Simon (2005) Bakhtinian thought and introductory reader, Newyourk: Routledge.
Dentith, Simon (2005) Bakhtinian thought and introductory reader, Newyourk: Routledge.
Hosseini, Fereshte Sadat, (2018), Grotesque in Iranian Art and Literature, Qazvin: Adib. (In Persian)
Jalili, Reza, and Mashoor, Parvindokht, (2016), "Analysis of Carnival Components in the collection of Havaye Tazeh (Fresh Air) by Ahmad Shamlou with an approach to Bakhtin's opinions", Literary Criticism Studies, Year 12, Number 46: 69-94. (In Persian)
Jezini, Javad, (2010), "Heterogeneity of feeling, a look at the book Grotesque in literature written by Philip Thompson", Surah, special issue of fiction literature: 102-105. DOI: DOI: 10.52547/jls.6.17.5 (In Persian)
Knowles, Ronald, (2011), Shakespeare and Carnival after Bakhtin, translated by Roya Pourazer, Tehran: Hermes. (In Persian)
Makaryk, Irena Rima, (2008), Encyclopedia of Contemporary Literary Theories, Mehran Mohajer and Mohammad Nabavi, Tehran: Aghah. (In Persian)
Pooyandeh, Mohammad Jaafar, (2016), An Introduction to the Sociology of Literature, 2nd edition, Tehran: Nashcheshmeh. (In Persian)
Rahhal, Abdul Wahed, (2019), "Grotesque discourse in the Algerian novel, an approach to the novels: Raas al-Mehanah by Ezzaldin Jalaweji and Al-Wali Al-Tahir yarfaa'o yadayhe biddoa'a by Tahir Wattar", Ishkalat magazine in language and literature, volume 8, number 2: 145-166. (In Arabic)
Sharbatdar, Keyvan, and Ansari, Shohreh, (2013), "Grotesque and fiction, examining the concept of grotesque and exploring its examples in the short stories of Shahriar Mandanipour", Contemporary Persian Literature, second year, number two: 105-121. (In Persian)
Taslim Jahormi, Fatemeh and Talebian, Yahya, (2018), "Combination of heterogeneous and opposite feelings (grotesque) in humor and satire", literary techniques, third year, number1: 1-20. (In Persian)
Thompson, Philip, (2017), Grotesque in Literature, translated by Farzaneh Taheri, Tehran: Nashre Markaz.
Vice, Sue (1997), Introducing Bakhtin, Manchester university press.