Reflection of polyphonic effects in the novel "The Snow Comes from the Window" by Hanna Mina based on Bakhtin's theory

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Arabic Language and Literature, Farhangian University, Tehran, Iran

2 PhD candidate in Arabic language and literature, Abadan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Abadan, Iran

3 PhD candidate in Arabic language and literature, Hakim Sabzevari University, Sabzevar, Iran

10.22034/mcal.2025.22293.2437

Abstract

Introduction: There are two general categories in relation to novel analysis: novels whose purpose is to serve the author's beliefs, and novels whose characters do not seek to confirm the author's words and whose aim is not to prove a single theme. The first category of novels, known as monologue novels, require a passive reader until the end of the story, who accompanies a character with the help of the narrator, and the story continues with his plot and thoughts. In such works, the possibility of readers understanding the same concept from the novel's text is expected; But second-rate novels have a mixed form, and it is difficult to draw a clear line between them. In such dialogues, "sometimes the voice of the author is heard, sometimes the voice of the character, sometimes the background voices of the narrator, and sometimes the voices of culture, society, politics, ideology, and attitudes contemporary with the writing or those that were in use in the past." The term "polyphony" first appeared in music and was introduced into fields such as criticism and studies by Bakhtin in the first half of the twentieth century. From this theorist's perspective, the novel's maturity is exemplified by the "polyphonic" novel, because the characters in "polyphonic" novels are multiple and have different voices, and the focus of the story does not rely on one or two characters, but rather the perspectives of all the characters in the novel are present, like a society in which all individuals participate. In this type of novel, people's voices are more important than their faces, and domineering and limiting voices have no place.

Methodology: This research is based on descriptive and analytical method. This article aims to first explain the term "polyphony" from Bakhtin's point of view and after a brief review of the author's situation and the introduction of the novel, analyze the characteristics and examples of "polyphony" in the said novel.



Results and discussion: The text of the novel "Al-Thalj Yaati Men Al-nafezah" shows the internal conflicts of "Fayyaz" and the reflection of the sounds of the surrounding environment on his character, as a result of which these sounds are imposed on him, we witness the emergence of a restless personality. He has a lot of doubt and makes a new decision every moment. In this novel, mutual concepts such as confidentiality and non-confidentiality, consent and non-consent, etc. are observed; Mutual concepts whose role is not erased or ineffective anywhere in the novel. Based on this, there are several different sounds. In this novel, the conversation is to express different points of view. In fact, most of the events of this story proceed with dialogue. In this novel, each of the characters in the novel are representatives of different social bases, which, in addition to distinguishing the individuality of the characters independently, reveals their different ideologies, and sometimes the confrontation of these opinions highlights the "multi-voice" nature of the work. By using the "polyphonic" technique, the author allows the characters of the novel to stand up for themselves and not be condemned all the time. In the mentioned novel, with the disappearance of the complete mastery of the narrator, the equal power of the characters and the narrator in expressing their opinions turns into their competition with each other. In addition, the dialogue in this novel is not a tool to depict the events and hide the narrator or the author, but it is a goal that can be used to measure the amount of conflict and incoherence between the voices of the story, and the reason for this is that the dialogue has different levels. is thought Apart from this, the dialogue has caused the elimination of one-sided and ideological views in the novel. Fayyaz's hidden conflict in the mentioned novel is the result of his internal conflict with the voices formed in his mind, the voices imposed on him by the society and the people around him. In this novel, Fayyaz's argument is manifested in the form of voices across each other and at the same time. He reveals the dimension of suffering and crying resulting from the separation of the homeland, comrades, friends and acquaintances and prefers captivity over exile.

Conclusion: In this article, the study of "Polyphony" in the novel "Al-Thalj Yaati Men Al-nafezah" was discussed, and important results were obtained from this passage, the most important of which are:

- As a "multi-voice" novel, this novel gives us a chance to think, neither the author's voice is loud in it, nor the characters' voices.

- In this novel, the narrator is a third person or omniscient; But the number of narrators is also evident in it. When the novel is narrated from the third person language, the perspective of Fayaz's character is external, and when the novel is narrated from the first person language, the perspective changes towards Fayaz and becomes an internal perspective.

- The existence of elements such as the structure of mutual concepts, "polyphonic" among the social classes present in the novel, the presence of characters with two opposite dimensions, and multilingualism confirm the polyphonic nature of the text. In addition, the polyphonic nature of the mentioned novel allows us to understand the presence of the narrator in the role of the hidden narrator (third person), the endless internal and external conflicts of opposing voices, and the non-declaration of the victory of one voice over other voices on the part of the narrative text and the narrator.

- In this novel, there are discourse contradictions around an event, namely Fayyaz's struggles. And in fact, different discourse trends can be inferred in the novel. Interpretability, lack of dominance of ideology and the same point of view on the novel and lack of dogmatism of the author in creating a single story picture for the audience are prominent aspects of this wok.

Keywords: Bakhtin, polyphonic, Hanna Mineh, " Al-Thalj Yaati Men Al-nafezah ".

Keywords


Ahmadi, Babak (2009), Structure and Interpretation of the Text, 11th edition, Tehran: Markaz Publication,
Bakhtin, Mikhail, (1384), Conversational Imagination, essays about the novel, translated by: Azin Hosseinzadeh, Tehran: Center for Artistic Studies and Research of the Ministry of Culture and Guidance. [In Persian].
Bakhtin, Mikhail (1986), Issues of Creative Art in Dostoevsky, translated by: Jamil Nasif Al-Takriti, 1st ed., Baghdad: Dar Al-Shu’un Al-Thaqafiya, [In Arabic].
Borunov, Roland; And Ouellet, Rial (1991), The World of the Novel, Baghdad: House of General Cultural Affairs, [In Arabic].
Boris, Eichenbaum (1982), The Theory of Formal Method: Texts of the Russian Formalists, translated by: Ibrahim Khatib, Arab Research Foundation, [In Arabic].
Boaza, Mohammad, (1996), "Al-Bolifiniya al-Rawa'i", Magazine of Al-Fakr al-Arabi, Issue 33, [In Arabic].
Talawi, Muhammad Najib, (2000), The Viewpoint in Al-Aswat al-Arabiya, Damascus: Ittihad al-Kitab al-Arab. [In Arabic].
Todorov, Tzutan, (1996), Mikhail Bakhtin's Al-Mubadad al-Hawari, translated by: Fakhri Saleh, 3rd edition, Beirut: Al-Mistesse Al-Arabiya for Studies and Publishing, [In Arabic].
Todorov, Tzotan (1998), Bakhtin's Dialogic Logic, translated by Dariush Karimi, Tehran: Markaz Publishing House, [In Persian].
Ramin Nia, Maryam, (2018), "study and analysis of polyphony in Mawlawi's Masnavi", Ph. D. Thesis of Persian Language and Literature, Tehran: Tarbiat Madras University, [In Persian].
Al-Eid, Yemeni (1999 AD), Narrative Techniques in Light of the Structural Approach, 2nd ed., Beirut: Dar Al-Farabi, [In Arabic].
Gholamhosseinzadeh, Gharib Reza (2007), Mikhail Bakhtin's Life, Thoughts and Fundamental Concepts, Tehran: Rouzegar Publishing, [In Persian].
Qabadi, Hossein Ali and colleagues, (2009, "Polyvoicity and the logic of dialogue in Maulavi's view on the issue of effort and trust based on the story of Shir and Nakhjiran", Literary Surveys, No. 170, pp, 71-94, [In Persian].
Kurdi, Abd al-Rahim, (2006), Al-Sard in the Contemporary Novel, Cairo: Al-Adab Library. (InArabic).
Kohnmouipour, Jhaleh, (2007), "Polyphony in fiction texts", Journal of Human Sciences, No, 57, pp, 397- 414. [In Persian].
Lodge, David et al., (2010), Theories of the Novel from Realism to Postmodernism, translated by Hossein Payandeh, vol. 2, Tehran: Niloufar. [In Persian].
Minah, Hanna, (1977), Al-Thalj Yaati Men Al-nafezah, Second edition, Beirut: Dar al-Adab. [In Arabic].
Al-Nabulsi, Shaker, (1992), Mubahej al-Huriyah fi Al-Rawaiya al-Arabiya,1st edition,Lebnan: Al-Arabiya Foundation for Studies and Publishing.[In Arabic].
Nobakht, Mohsen, (2013), "Multiple Voices and Multiple Characters in Iran's Postmodern Novel, with a Look at the Novel Asfar Kataban by Abu Torab Khosravi", Research Institute of Humanities and Cultural Studies, Language of Knowledge, Year 3, Number 2 pp,120-85. [In Persian].
Humphrey, Robert, (1975), Tiar al-Wa'i in al-Rawaiya al-Hadith, Translation: Mahmoud al-Rabi'i. Cairo: Dar al-Maarif. [In Arabic].